Hello, I must be going
SHOULD THEY STAY OR SHOULD THEY GO? That’s the question hundreds of parents and student-athletes in Georgia’s Clayton County are asking, as school system leaders desperately try to hold on to their accreditation. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution’s S. Thomas Coleman explains the dilemma these families are facing …
To leave or not to leave.
That is the question being asked — and in some cases answered — right now by hundreds of parents and student-athletes in Clayton County. And hundreds more will have to face the issue as Clayton school system leaders try desperately to hold on to their accreditation.
The National Accreditation Commission has voted to revoke the district’s accreditation unless it meets nine conditions by Sept. 1. If the credentials of the Clayton County schools are yanked, next year’s graduates will not be eligible for the HOPE Scholarship and could find it hard to be admitted to many of the nation’s colleges and universities.
Last week, the Georgia High School Association weighed in by voting to extend hardship status to Clayton County student-athletes who transfer to other schools — making them eligible to compete immediately without moving — if their district loses its accreditation.
But there’s a catch. If the district meets the nine mandates by Sept. 1 and keeps its accreditation, students who have transferred — and started school and practice sessions for fall sports at new schools in early August — will not be eligible to compete without moving into the new district.
So the decision is not so simple, especially for parents like James King of Stockbridge, who taught his kids how to play chess when they were very young in an effort to keep their minds sharp.
His son, Josh, will be a sophomore defensive back at Mt. Zion and runs track as a member of the 400- and 1,600-meter relay teams.
King’s daughter, Jasmine, will be a senior at Morrow. She is an honor-roll student, and a three-year starter and team captain of the volleyball team that has advanced to the state tournament for two consecutive years.
Right now, King plans to keep Josh at Mt. Zion, but Jasmine is likely on her way to another school.
“With Josh, we like what’s going on at Mt. Zion, with the school and the athletic program,� King said last week. “They have a good group of kids, and so we’re going to give the school system a year to see if they can get things worked out.
“Jasmine is a different story,� King said. “She’s going into her senior year, and it’s a crucial year for her, athletically and academically.�
King said Jasmine is being recruited for sports by a number of small colleges. But if she transfers now, she will have to learn a new system and new teammates, and it could all be rendered moot if Clayton keeps its accreditation and she is ineligible to compete for her new school.
But if she remains at Morrow and the district losesits accreditation, all of the honors and advanced placement classes she has taken could be for naught if she is denied admission to the college of her choice.
“It’s a tough decision,� King said. “Really, when you look at scholarships that could be involved, it’s a $20,000 question.
“With her, we can’t afford to wait. We’re looking into some other schools now. Her future is too important for us to gamble and hope that the board gets things right.�
Jasmine is ready to transfer, and she said most of her teammates are as well.
“On one hand it’s sad because I was looking forward to being a team captain and a four-year starter [at Morrow],� Jasmine said. “But on the other hand, I’ve worked too hard to possibly not be able to get into the college I want because of some decisions adults have made. I don’t want to leave my future in their hands.�
Pamela Walker agrees. Her son, Devon Miller, makes As and Bs in eighth grade at Point South Middle School in Jonesboro and is a promising football and track athlete. She has decided to send Devon to another school — either in Cobb County, where he will live with her brother, or in Dekalb County, where he will live with his godparents.
“The school board actually made the decision for me,� said Walker, who is looking into private schools for Devon’s little brother, Kameron Miller, a fifth-grader in the gifted program at Point South Elementary. “When I went to the last school board meeting and saw how they looked down their noses at people who were passionately giving their comments, and how they just cut people off, I saw they didn’t have any respect for the community or the students. I can’t have them making more decisions that will impact my children.�
While Marc Nichols is equally disgusted with the Clayton school board, he hasn’t made a final decision yet for his daughter, Iesha Nichols, a sophomore on the track team at Mundy’s Mill and member of the Tigers’ defending state champion 400-meter relay team.
“I tend to look at things with the big picture in mind, and that’s what I want to do here after I gather as much information as possible,� said Nichols, who is contacting the NCAA Clearinghouse to find out how it handles student-athletes who come from school systems that are not accredited.
“People need to really be thoughtful about this decision,� Nichols said. “And I don’t think people have considered the impact that all of this will have on the other school systems around Clayton.�
One system, Henry County, does not plan to take Clayton transfers unless they move into the county. Athletics director Justin White said Henry’s eight high schools are full.
“We have to base our decisions on what’s fair to the taxpayers of Henry County,� White said.
Officials at two nearby private schools — Our Lady of Mercy in Fairburn and Eagle’s Landing Christian Academy in McDonough — said they also are watching the situation in Clayton.
Our Lady of Mercy athletics director William Schmitz said any Clayton County student will be considered for acceptance at any time, but will not be given special consideration for coming from a school system in crisis. They must complete the same comprehensive enrollment procedure as any other student.
Eagle’s Landing Christian’s principal, Chuck Gilliam, said the school’s rising 11th- and 12th-grade classes are near capacity. Adding another section, which would be necessary if a number of students from Clayton County are interested in transferring, would be hard to do at this late date.
Jonesboro volleyball coach Dan Maehlman said he is frustrated that he can’t give his returning players and their parents complete information. It’s a dilemma that all fall sport coaches in Clayton are dealing with.
“I can’t give them any more information because they’re not giving it to us,� Maehlman said. “You get so frustrated when you look at your kids, it makes you want to cry.�

tag this